Why don't you guys used what we cooked up at my community, its more specific in terms of punishments and actually what is Contraban. Add what you want to it. Hope you enjoy it.
Level 1
Contraband: Weaponry, Armoured clothing, Combine technology, large quantities of Level 1 and/or 2 contraband.
Punishment: Long term detainment, interrogation, heavy beatings, amputation.
Level 2
Contraband: Unauthorized electronic equipment, pre-war technology, makeshift weaponry, makeshift armour, high-level narcotics.
Punishment: Coarse beatings, detainment.
Level 3
Contraband: Unauthorized clothing, low level narcotics, low level alcohol, pre-war art and cultural material.
Punishment: Minor beatings, caution.
Punishments are up to the unit on-scene. This list exists to prevent unnecessary radio traffic.
I've seen this same list used for years now. However if its not broke don't fix it, and there's a reason it has never been changed. Stickied and Locked